Hello and welcome back to the blog here at Dan DuBois Law. Here on the blog, we like to distribute available information to the public to help educate the populace of WNY.

Driving While Intoxicated (DWI) is a serious offense in New York, and the state's laws are designed to penalize impaired driving harshly. While most people associate DWI charges with alcohol, it's important to understand that impairment due to drugs—whether they're illegal substances, or legal items like prescription medications or marijuana—can also lead to a DWI charge. However, the legal landscape for drug-related DWIs is different in significant ways from those involving alcohol. Understanding these differences is crucial for drivers in New York who wish to avoid the severe consequences of a drug-related DWI conviction.

Understanding DWI Laws in New York

In New York, DWI is defined as operating a vehicle while impaired by alcohol, drugs, or a combination of both. For alcohol-related cases, the law sets a clear threshold: a Blood Alcohol Concentration (BAC) of 0.08% or higher is considered legally intoxicated. However, when it comes to drug-related DWIs, the law doesn't set a specific measurement or threshold for impairment. Instead, it considers whether the driver's ability to operate the vehicle was impaired "to any extent" by drugs.

Alcohol-Related DWI

When a driver is suspected of alcohol impairment, the law enforcement officers typically use breathalyzer tests or field sobriety tests to measure the driver's BAC. These tests are standardized and widely accepted in court. A BAC of 0.08% or more usually results in an automatic DWI charge. For commercial drivers, the threshold is even lower at 0.04%. These tests provide tangible numbers that make proving alcohol impairment relatively straightforward.

Drug-Related DWI

Drug-related DWIs, however, present a more complex challenge. Unlike alcohol, where the BAC provides a clear measure of impairment, drugs affect individuals differently, and there's no "legal limit" for drug impairment. The substances considered under drug-related DWIs can range from illegal drugs like cocaine or heroin to legally prescribed medications and even marijuana.

To assess impairment, law enforcement often relies on specially trained officers known as Drug Recognition Experts (DREs). DREs use a 12-step evaluation process, which includes checking the driver's pulse, examining their eyes, and conducting a series of coordination tests. In some cases, blood tests may be used to detect the presence of drugs in the driver's system, but unlike alcohol, the presence of a drug alone isn't always enough to prove impairment. This makes drug-related DWIs more legally complex and often requires additional evidence to secure a conviction.

Legal Consequences of DWIs in New York

Both alcohol-related and drug-related DWIs carry severe penalties, including fines, jail time, and the suspension or revocation of driving privileges. However, the consequences can vary depending on the type of impairment and the specifics of the case.

Penalties for Alcohol-Related DWI

For alcohol-related DWIs, penalties are largely determined by the driver's BAC level and any aggravating factors, such as prior offenses or the presence of minors in the vehicle. A first-time offense with a BAC just over the limit might result in a fine, short-term license suspension, and potential jail time. However, higher BAC levels or repeat offenses can lead to more severe penalties, including extended license suspension, higher fines, and longer jail sentences. Additionally, a DWI conviction will significantly impact the driver's record and insurance premiums.

Penalties for Drug-Related DWI

Penalties for drug-related DWIs can be as severe as, or even more severe than, those for alcohol-related offenses. One major difference is the legal complexity surrounding drug-related DWIs. Since proving impairment by drugs can be more challenging, the prosecution may bring additional charges related to drug possession or distribution if illegal substances are found. Even legally prescribed drugs can lead to a DWI conviction if they impair the driver's ability to operate a vehicle safely, complicating the defense and potentially leading to harsher penalties.

The Role of Chemical Tests in DWI Cases

Chemical tests play a critical role in both alcohol and drug-related DWI cases, but their application and implications differ.

Contesting Test Results

While breathalyzer tests and blood tests are central to DWI cases, these tests aren't infallible. Drivers have the right to challenge the accuracy of these tests, especially in drug-related cases where proving impairment is less straightforward. Expert witnesses can dispute the results by questioning the testing procedures, the timing of the tests, and the interpretation of the results, offering potential avenues for defense.

Legal Defenses for Drug-Related DWI

Defending against drug-related DWI charges often involves challenging the prosecution's evidence of impairment. Since the presence of drugs in a driver's system doesn't automatically mean they were impaired, the defense might focus on the relevance of prescription drugs, the legality of the drug in question, and whether the DRE's evaluation was conducted properly.

Impact on Drivers' Lives

A DWI conviction, whether related to alcohol or drugs, can have long-term consequences. These include difficulties in securing employment, professional licensing issues, and higher insurance rates. However, drug-related DWIs can carry additional social stigmas, particularly if illegal substances are involved, which might further impact the individual's personal and professional life.

Seeking Legal Help

Given the complexities of drug-related DWI cases, it's crucial to seek experienced legal counsel. A skilled DWI defense attorney understands the nuances of New York law and can help navigate the challenges of proving or disproving impairment in drug-related cases. When facing a DWI charge, look for an attorney with a strong track record in handling similar cases, who can effectively challenge the prosecution's evidence and protect your rights. Or, rather than searching “Best DWI lawyers near me”, you can call Dan DuBois Law, and get the best in the business.

You Need the Best DWI Lawyers on Your Side in Buffalo 

Drug-related DWIs in New York are treated differently from alcohol-related cases, with more legal complexities and potentially harsher penalties. Understanding these differences is vital for anyone driving in New York. If you or someone you know is facing a drug-related DWI charge, don't hesitate to seek experienced legal representation to help navigate the legal process and achieve the best possible outcome.

Remember to stay up to date with our blog, where we regularly go over these higher-level looks at NY Law, go over the process of arrest, and more. Don't just take our word for it, check out our Recommendations and Google Reviews! Everyone deserves the best representation to prove their side, which is why we have financing plans to be flexible for you

DISCLAIMER: PAST RESULTS DO NOT GUARANTEE FUTURE RESULTS. DANIEL DUBOIS AND ANY DUBOIS LAW ATTORNEYS ARE NOT YOUR ATTORNEYS UNLESS RETAINED. INFORMATION SHARED HERE IS FOR INFORMATIONAL AND EDUCATIONAL PURPOSES ONLY. EACH CASE IS UNIQUE AND IS DECIDED BASED ON ITS OWN FACTS AND MERITS AND CANNOT BE COMPARED TO OTHER CASES WHICH MAY HAVE HAD DIFFERENT FACTS AND CIRCUMSTANCES.