Hello and welcome back to the blog here at Dan DuBois Law. Here on the blog, we like to distribute available information to the public to help educate the populace of WNY. Today, we wanted to take some time to talk about the differences between state and federal crimes, and what you need to know. 

Understanding the complexities of the legal world is crucial, particularly when it comes to distinguishing between federal and state crimes in New York. It's more than just legal jargon - it's about understanding your rights, the potential consequences, and how best to defend yourself.

Unraveling the Mystery: Federal vs. State Crimes

So, What's a Federal Crime Anyway?

Picture yourself in an episode of a hit crime series where agents swoop in, badges glistening in the sun. That's where we're starting - with federal crimes. These infractions violate laws passed by Congress. From moving illicit substances over state lines to identity theft, these cases are handled by agencies like the DEA and FBI, and prosecuted by the US Attorney's Office.

State Crimes: More Common than You'd Think

Conversely, state crimes are offenses that break state laws. Ones you'd be more likely to be affected by. From things like traffic violations to burglary and bar brawls, they're investigated by the local police department, and prosecuted by the Erie County DA here in Buffalo. The next time you read about or see a robbery or something on the news, now you know that's probably a state crime! 

The Jurisdictional Battle: Federal vs State

What is Jurisdiction?

Jurisdiction refers to who has the authority to prosecute a crime. Determining jurisdiction will often depend on the location of the crime and its nature. Imagine that court is like a game - jurisdiction is like the rulebook under which you're playing. Depending on the house rules, there could be slight variations, which is why determining who has the authority is so important. 

Federal Jurisdiction Explained

Federal jurisdiction isn't something that's invoked lightly. It generally applies when the crime plays out on a larger canvas - think federal property or crimes that involve crossing state lines. You're likely in federal territory if you find yourself counterfeiting money, hijacking an airplane, or orchestrating a complex internet fraud scheme (Note that these examples are not an exhaustive list).

State Jurisdiction Explained

State jurisdiction is a more familiar beast. It typically applies when a crime is committed within the state's boundaries and breaks the state law. So if you're involved in a car theft, a mugging, or a case of domestic violence within New York, you'll be answerable to the state

Crimes Under Both Jurisdictions

Some crimes, like drug trafficking or firearms offenses, can be prosecuted both federally and by the state. This means defendants can face double the trouble - being tried twice for the same offense without it violating double jeopardy rules.

Differences in Legal Procedures

Federal Court Procedures

From investigation to trial, federal court procedures are typically more complex and have stricter rules. Federal prosecutors often have more resources than their state counterparts, and federal sentences can be more severe.

State Court Procedures

State court procedures vary from state to state. In New York, the process typically involves an arrest, arraignment, pre-trial motions, a trial, and potentially, sentencing. We've covered a few of these in our other blog posts, check them out! 

Comparing Penalties and Sentencing 

Federal Crime Sentencing

Find yourself committing a federal crime, and you may find the consequences reverberating around your life like the aftershocks of an earthquake.  The penalties for federal crimes are often steep and leave little wiggle room, determined by federal sentencing guidelines. Between hefty fines and lengthy imprisonment, the impact can last for a long, long time. 

State Crime Sentencing

In the Empire State, the scale of penalties for state crimes is as varied as in New York itself. It's a reflection of the crime's severity and your criminal history. For some, it might mean facing the inside of a jail cell. For others, it could be probation, fines, or giving back to the community through service. It's a mixed bag, illustrating that in New York, justice is about more than just punishment – it's about reform and second chances too.

Differences in Parole and Probation

One key difference is the system of parole. While parole is commonly used in state sentences, the federal system largely abolished parole in the 1980s, replacing it with supervised release.

Defending Federal vs. State Crimes

Defense Strategies for Federal Crimes

Federal defense requires thorough preparation, knowledge of federal laws, and an understanding of the federal court system. The role of a federal defense attorney is critical in devising effective defense strategies. Remember, in federal cases, the prosecution is the United States Attorney's Office, extremely well-funded and experienced.

Defense Strategies For State Crimes

Defending state crimes also requires a deep understanding of laws and procedures, specifically those as set by New York State in our case. Your lifeline in state battles is an experienced defense attorney with a comprehensive strategy tailored to your situation. Here at Dan DuBois Law, we're dedicated to fighting for your rights, guiding you through the legal system, helping you understand your rights, and representing you in court.

Get In Touch With An Experienced NY Defense Attorney Today

If you or a loved one is facing charges, don't hesitate to seek legal counsel immediately. An informed defendant is an empowered one. Take the first step towards understanding and protecting your rights today. We understand it's a stressful time. Here at DuBois Law, we understand, we never judge. Check out our FAQ page if you're unsure about needing a NY lawyer to represent you and defend your innocence. We think it's always worth it, and the first consultation is free. 

Make sure to stay up to date with our blog! We regularly post small snippets of legal updates here and you don't want to miss a thing. You can check out coverage of our clients in the news here, and get a wider array of recommendations from previous clients here.

See where Dan DuBois and DuBois Law specialize by checking out our practice area page. Click on one of the defense areas from the menu dropdown or one of the links from the list in that page to get a more detailed glimpse of our philosophy surrounding it. Remember, here at DuBois Law, we understand, we never judge. Give us a call today at (888)-NTGULTY [(888)-684-8589] or fill out our contact form to request a consultation.

DISCLAIMER: PAST RESULTS DO NOT GUARANTEE FUTURE RESULTS, AND THE OUTCOME OF YOUR PARTICULAR CASE OR MATTER CANNOT BE PREDICTED USING A LAWYER'S OR LAW FIRM'S PAST RESULTS. EACH CASE IS UNIQUE AND SHOULD BE EVALUATED THROUGH A PHONE CALL OR MEETING WITH DANIEL DUBOIS, WITHOUT COMPARISON TO OTHER CASES WHICH MAY HAVE HAD DIFFERENT FACTS AND CIRCUMSTANCES.